Survival of the Fittest

Wildflower Planting, January 31, 2021

Wetland Planting, January 31, 2021


Charles Darwin first wrote about the concept of natural selection in his book, The Origin of Species, published on 24 November 1859.  In it, he wrote extensively about how nature tends to sort species out within natural communities over time - choosing the ones most adapted to survive and those that are not to disappear. It remains one of the most important concepts in understanding ecology to this day and it influences planted communities as much as natural ones.

We sometimes fail to understand this fully when we design landscapes, whether at home or in restoration projects. What we fail to fully comprehend is that our artificial plantings will adhere to the same tenets of natural selection that direct the natural plantings in the world around us. Our landscapes are communities, even if they are artificial ones. We can try to put our meddling hands on them, but eventually nature and natural selection will win out. 

This has once again been brought home to me here in my relatively new landscape in Holiday. I no longer have all of the plant species I started with nor do I have the same general design. Plant species have disappeared and others have moved around. As some have prospered, they have taken up space that some of the others seemingly needed. Some simply disappeared - not returning the next spring after seemingly doing fine the months before. It is what I expected, and what every gardener should expect, if planting a community instead of a monoculture of just one species. Even then, it is always disquieting finding out that certain species you desire are not adapted to your community.

For a few, I have moved them elsewhere in places where they will have more "elbow room". My once-thriving patches of Georgia aster (Symphyotrichum georgianum) struggled last summer and disappeared by late fall without flowering. I've moved a few to my backyard plantings where they have virtually no competition. It wasn't a failure in providing the right soil and water conditions, I believe, but one of crowding from more-aggressive plants. The same is true for my butterfly milkweed (Asclepias tuberosa). In the first summer, this species did amazingly well and set large numbers of seed. Last summer, I did not get a single seed pod. They are just getting crowded out. If I want to maintain it, I will have to move some to a new area in the back. The front community is full.

I have always valued diversity, but I'm realistic enough to know that not every member of my community plays well together. I have lost 2 of my 4 goldenrods (Solidago spp.), but the two others have reseeded and suckered a bit to fill a much larger space than I once envisioned. The pinebarren frostweed (Crocanthemum corymbosusm) has spread outward from its original space to cover far more space than I desire. I will likely weed it back a bit later this winter, but it has a firm hold in my community and I respect that.  For those of us who design and plant a meadow-type planting, we need to accept that some of our initial members will thrive and some will not. We need to embrace the species who reward us with dependable growth. We can mourn those that don't, but we can only add them into a different planting or remain frustrated. After all, a community of plants will adhere to the concept of natural selection and ultimately the most fit will survive despite our best intentions.
 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Wildflower Meadows - The Importance of Grasses

Image
A Natural Wildflower "Meadow" - Apalachicola National Forest I grew up in the prairie Midwest and was fortunate to have been caught up in the prairie restoration movement that blazed brightly in the last few decades of this past century. Very little of our original prairie ecosystems remain as the rich prairie soils were quickly converted to agricultural uses as European settlers swarmed their way over the continent.  These ecosystems are extremely diverse, regardless of where they occur. From the tall-grass prairies of the Midwest to the rockland prairies of the Mid-South and the true dry prairie systems here in Florida where I now reside, there are several universal characteristics - they are some of the most species diverse systems in the world and they are dominated by grasses. Grasses, in all their many shapes and forms, are what form the foundation of any "meadow." That must also be true for all the "wildflower meadows" I see extolled on s
Read more

The Ethics of Collecting Seed

Image
I've been writing lately about seeds and using them to create what is often called a pollinator meadow. A great many of the plants in my new landscape were grown from seed. Frankly, I have always loved sowing seeds and watching them sprout. I started in early childhood and I've been doing it since. It's rewarding and the anticipation of waiting for seeds to sprout is difficult to match unless you play the lottery. I rarely purchase seeds. I collect them. When I can, I purchase a few plants of a species I wish to add to my landscape and I then collect their seed after they bloom. If a plant doesn't prosper sufficiently to set seed for me, it is not a plant I wish to continue to grow. Over the years, I've tried a great many plants that I've failed to adequately provide for. Today in my landscape, I'm trying a few that I've never tried before. The exceptions come from plants that are not available in the trade. To grow these from seed, I need to collect
Read more

A Pollinator Garden is More than Wildflowers

Image
A natural grass-dominated meadow in the shade Splitbeard bluestem - Andropogon ternarius Lopsided Indiangrass - Sorghastrum secundum Sites on social media that are promoting pollinator gardens are rife with posts about wildflowers. Folks seeking to make their landscapes pollinator friendly seem to be almost-universally focused on wildflowers. What these well-meaning people seem to not understand is the importance of native grasses. Meadows, prairies, and other wildflower-dominated systems are mostly grass. Grasses form the backbone of every one of these plant communities. It isn't the wildflowers. They simply provide most of the color - but a living landscape is not about color, it's about creating habitat, and this habitat requires us to incorporate native grasses. It is true that the vast majority of grasses, and their graminoid relatives, are wind pollinated. They do not provide nectar and pollen for the most part, but despite that they are significant. More s
Read more